When the Tools Don’t Work Like Magic (And What That Actually Means)
I tried using the 5 Senses Check-In last Thursday.
I was spiraling about a deadline. Heart racing. Chest tight. Thoughts spinning.
I remembered the tool. I actually DID the tool.
5 things I can see.
4 things I can touch.
3 things I can hear.
2 things I can smell.
1 thing I can taste.
And then…
I was still anxious.
Not cured. Not suddenly Zen. Just slightly less panicked and honestly, a little annoyed that the tool didn’t work the way I thought it would.
Here’s what no one tells you about learning mindset tools: they don’t work like magic.
You learn the tools. You try them. And sometimes, maybe even most of the time at first, they don’t immediately fix the problem.
And that’s when people quit.
“I tried meditation and I’m still stressed, so clearly it doesn’t work.”
“I used the reframe and I still feel anxious, so what’s the point?”
“I did the thing and nothing changed, so I must be doing it wrong.”
But here’s what I’ve learned: the tools not working like magic doesn’t mean they’re not working.
The Lie We Tell Ourselves About Tools
We have this fantasy about how mindset tools are supposed to work:
You learn the tool → You use it once → Problem solved forever.
Like flipping a light switch. Instant transformation.
But that’s not how this works.
Mindset tools aren’t light switches. They’re weights at the gym.
You don’t do one bicep curl and wake up with massive arms. You do one bicep curl and… nothing visibly changes.
But if you keep doing bicep curls, consistently, imperfectly, even when you don’t see results, eventually, your arms get stronger.
Mindset tools work the same way.
The 5 Senses Check-In didn’t cure my anxiety last Thursday.
But it interrupted the spiral.
It brought me back to the present for about 30 seconds.
It gave me just enough space to take the next breath.
And that’s how it works.
Not magic. Not instant.
Just… slightly better than it would’ve been without the tool.
What “Working” Actually Looks Like
“Working” doesn’t mean the problem disappears.
It means you handle it 5% better than you would have without the tool.
That’s it.
You meditate and your mind still wanders? It’s working. You’re practicing bringing it back.
You use a reframe and you still feel anxious? It’s working. You interrupted the spiral.
You do the “So What?” Ladder and you still worry? It’s working. You noticed the pattern sooner.
Progress isn’t “I’m cured.”
Progress is “I spiraled for 10 minutes instead of 2 hours.”
Progress is “I noticed the thought sooner.”
Progress is “I used the tool even though I didn’t feel like it.”
That’s what working looks like.
Most people quit because they’re waiting for magic.
The Messy Middle No One Warns You About
There’s a phase, the messy middle, where you know the tools, you’re using them… and they still feel awkward, forced, and ineffective.
You’re doing everything “right,” but it’s not smooth. It’s not natural. And it definitely doesn’t feel like it’s working.
This is where most people quit.
“I’ve been meditating for two weeks, and I still overthink everything. This is pointless.”
But the messy middle isn’t failure.
It’s the process.
Think about learning to drive. At first, you’re consciously thinking about everything: mirrors, pedals, signals, hands, speed.
It’s clunky. It’s slow. It feels hard.
But eventually, you don’t think about it at all. You just… drive.
Mindset tools are the same.
At first, they’re clunky. You have to remember to use them. They don’t feel natural.
But if you stay in the messy middle, if you keep using them even when they feel awkward, they become automatic.
The messy middle is where the transformation happens.
And most people quit before they ever get there.
How to Stay in the Messy Middle
1. Stop expecting magic.
The tool’s job isn’t to cure you. It’s to give you 5% more control. Lower the bar and you’ll actually see progress.
2. Celebrate micro-wins.
Remembering to use a tool is a win. Catching the spiral sooner is a win. Showing up imperfectly is a win.
3. Trust the process (even when you can’t see results).
You’re building neural pathways. You won’t feel it happening, but you’ll notice it later.
4. Stay in the discomfort.
Awkward doesn’t mean broken. It means learning.
What This Looks Like in Real Life
When I first started meditating, I thought it “wasn’t working” because my mind wandered constantly.
Then one day, about six weeks in, I noticed something unexpected.
I was catching my spirals in real life.
Not during meditation. During my actual day.
That’s when it clicked: meditation wasn’t quieting my mind. It was training me to notice when it wandered.
The tool was working. I just couldn’t see it yet.
Book Bite: When Things Fall Apart — Pema Chödrön
“Nothing ever goes away until it has taught us what we need to know.” -Pema Chödrön
Pema Chödrön is a Buddhist nun and teacher who writes about staying with discomfort instead of running from it. Her work isn’t about fixing what’s hard. It’s about being with it.
That’s exactly what the messy middle requires.
You stay with the discomfort of tools not working like magic.
You stay with the frustration of still feeling anxious.
You stay with the awkwardness of being bad at something new.
The tools are teaching you, but they can’t teach you if you quit the first time they don’t work perfectly.
The Bottom Line
The tools won’t work like magic.
You’ll still feel anxious.
Your mind will still wander.
You’ll still spiral sometimes.
That’s not failure. That’s the process.
5% better. Catching spirals sooner. Noticing patterns.
That’s progress.
Stay in it. Stay messy. Keep practicing.
That’s how this works.
Want weekly tools, real talk, and reminders that progress isn’t magic?
Sign up for The Mindset Drop newsletter. Every Thursday. One mindset shift. One tool. One simple step. No BS. Sign up here
